Rune Factory: A Fantasy Harvest Moon

Vespyr:
At first glance, Rune Factory looks like a happy little children’s game. It seems to revolve around harvesting and teenage romance. The game is full of character, but this fantasy/simulation seems a little slow.

Rune Factory is different from most of the other games I’ve played. It lies somewhere in the middle of Sim City and Final Fantasy, so it was hard to know what to expect. I am much more of a city girl than a country girl, and the idea of farming for fun seemed a bit foreign to me. However, I wanted to give it a fair chance.

One of my first assignments in the game was to clear a field, pulling weeds and moving natural debris. I had no problem clearing the field, but I could only clear one object at a time. After a few minutes, I figured out that I could store endless debris in my backpack, either for later use or to throw out en masse. I kept moving along the field, hoping to find a more efficient way to clear the field. I was disappointed to discover the large size of my field, and the entire field-clearing process took a whopping 12 minutes. The next day, I came back to review my progress and found that a scattering of weeds and debris has appeared overnight. After all that effort, my job was not over, and weeding would have to be a daily chore.

Perhaps my intense hatred of weeding from childhood influenced me, but I felt that it was time to get off my field and explore. My friend had sent me a hint on where to get an axe, so I went looking for the mansion in which it could be obtained. The tiny in-game map was little help, and I found myself frustrated by the lack of direction. There was no obvious linear path in this story and no townspeople politely hinting over and over again about a certain thing you “might want to do”. Instead, I found many townspeople with advice as diverse as their personalities, from the arrogant to the indifferent.

I ran around the town and eventually found my axe, but obtaining it from a woman in a mansion, which seemed counterintuitive. Why would a woman in such a fine place have such a brutal, basic tool? It didn’t make a lot of sense, and I started to get the feeling that this game was more about exploring more than achieving. It leaves so much up to the player that it begs to be explored, asking for hours of your time to wander and chat at your leisure. This structure doesn't really cater to my personality, as I often play games for measurable achievements and rewards, like an unraveling story.

I found myself continuing to be confused in this game. I played as a character that was an outsider with amnesia, and I began to feel that I was increasingly becoming a foreigner in this world. Skill levels were increasing, but it hardly had any meaning since I had no idea how I even obtained those skill points. Random pieces of dialogue were voiced, and often they didn’t match the text on the screen. The combat system was difficult to use, as I was fighting with a spade and had to be incredibly close to the enemy to even hit them. I couldn’t use the grid on the ground as a guide, as the monster could stand out of reach within a grid box.

Rune Factory is definitely a cute game and allows for an incredible amount of exploration. Aside from the oddly placed bits of audible dialogue, it seemed pretty cohesive. I feel that I have not given it enough time to explore the combat aspect, but the slow progression already took most of my patience. While Rune Factory seems like it may be a strong game, it is simply too open-ended for a goal-oriented player like myself.

Jettoki:
I picked up Rune Factory a couple weeks ago, unaware of what I was getting into. I’ve listened to enthusiastic praise for Harvest Moon’s accessible garden-simulation gameplay, nuanced crafting system, and endless sea of content – but most of this is from the mouth of my younger cousin, who expressed his excitement in the form of farm animal noises. It’s true – the game is marketed to children, and the too-charming presentation is clearly pasteurized for consumption by a very young demographic. But I would never let that stand in the way of my assessment of the game’s design, which is, for the most part, excellent.

I should start by pointing out that the story is unremarkable – perhaps purposefully so, because the game seems intent on pushing the player out the door into an open-ended narrative as quickly as possible. You play as Raguna, a boy who wandered into town with amnesia, only to be tasked with managing a farm for a woman named Mist. There are plenty of colorful characters to meet and converse with around town, and they not only have diverse personalities but also birthdays, pet peeves, and favorite foods, which you are encouraged to learn for the sake of earning friendships.

Surprisingly, finding romance is one of the primary goals in the game; players will court one of several girls in the village, and ultimately complete a series of crafting tasks which will result in marriage. While I’m not certain that this is the best message to send our children, the design is solidly founded on the legacy of Japanese dating sims, though obviously watered down and G-rated for the younger audience.

Core gameplay in Rune Factory mostly revolves around managing your farm; plowing fields, tending crops, and building additions onto your house. This may sound rather dull – Vespyr certainly thought so – but there is an inescapably addictive quality about a system that rewards the player for completing routine tasks. More importantly, after a few hours, the core gameplay takes a backseat to the numerous and more diverse tertiary goals, such as collecting resources for crafting and interacting with the virtual community.

The key to the simulation formula is the freedom and creativity it affords the player. In this category, Rune Factory succeeds remarkably – the player chooses which crops to grow, which crafting arts to pursue, and how best to turn a profit. Furthermore, the player can take up fun activities like fishing and mining early on, and the game encourages the player to make trips into the numerous local caves in order to find hidden spots where special crafting resources may be harvested.

There are some serious lessons here for MMO trade-systems designers – harvesting is so well integrated into the exploration aspect of the game that it never feels like a chore, and players are always rewarded for taking a few risks or putting in a little extra time. Crafting is similarly structured, and although it may lack the diversity of more adult-oriented roleplaying games, the system ensures that every crafted item has enough of a purpose to see some useage, as well as rewarding more attentive players who wish to craft products of the highest grade.

On a less favorable note, Rune Factory refuses to provide the player with much in the way of hints or tutorials, preferring instead to let him feel around for a few hours until things make sense. Several common tools cannot be obtained except by speaking with seemingly random people in town or reaching unwritten benchmarks. For example, the player won’t receive a hammer until he has plowed fifty tiles in the first cave and then spoken with the blacksmith, but this requirement is never mentioned until after the task has been completed. The ‘slow crawl to success’ model is reminiscent of older MMOs – pacing is mostly dependent upon the player’s foreknowledge of the genre.

Vespyr’s frustrations with Rune Factory demonstrate just how quickly its difficulty will alienate a large segment of the game’s potential market. The developers were probably hoping to reward exploration, and this would be fine, except the game commits the all-too-common sin of punishing players who choose not to explore. By punishing the player for opting out of some facet of gameplay, you are in effect making that facet mandatory – so why allow him to opt out in the first place?

Competitive-minded genre gamers may find the game’s difficulty appealing, but I don’t think this excuses the problem. However much Rune Factory may succeed as a sim, it fails to meet its potential simply by refusing to lend new players a helping hand. Even so, I’m perfectly willing to suffer the game’s shortcomings if it means gleaning so many valuable lessons in how to construct addictive, routine-based gameplay.